15-Year vs. 30-Year Fixed Mortgage: Which One Actually Saves You Money?

Figures come from official sources (IRS, SSA, USDA, Labor Department) and are re-checked at every update. How I fact-check

Photo by Get Lost Mike via Pexels

Key Takeaways

  • On a $400,000 loan at November 2026 rates, the 15-year costs $3,473 a month vs. $2,691 for the 30-year.
  • The 15-year saves about $343,000 in interest and is paid off 15 years sooner.
  • Paying the 15-year amount on a 30-year loan clears it in about 16 years and keeps a lower required payment.
  • Keep your debt-to-income (DTI) ratio comfortably under about 36% with the 15-year payment before choosing it.

If you’re choosing a mortgage term, this is the math I’d want to see first: what each option costs per month, what it costs over the life of the loan, and the in-between route most people overlook.

Freddie Mac’s weekly survey had the 30-year fixed at 7.11% and the 15-year at 6.45% on November 12, 2026. That’s a gap of about two-thirds of a point. I track those rates week to week in my mortgage rates and home prices update.

The $400,000 Comparison at Today’s Rates

Here’s principal and interest on the same $400,000 loan four ways. Taxes and insurance aren’t included.

Option Monthly payment Paid off in Total interest
30-year at 7.11% $2,691 30 years $568,697
30-year, plus one extra payment a year $2,691 + one extra About 24 years About $432,700
30-year, paying the 15-year amount $3,473 About 16 years About $274,300
15-year at 6.45% $3,473 15 years $225,220

The 15-year costs about $782 more a month. In return it saves roughly $343,000 in interest, and the loan is gone 15 years sooner.

That’s not a rounding error.

That’s a bigger trade than it was in the summer, when both rates were lower. Higher rates make the long loan’s interest pile up faster, so the shorter term saves more dollars now.

Can Your Budget Carry the 15-Year Payment?

The usual test is your debt-to-income ratio (DTI): every monthly debt payment, including the new mortgage, taxes and insurance, divided by your gross monthly income. I’d want that comfortably under about 36% with the 15-year payment in it. Lenders will often approve more, but approval isn’t the same as comfortable.

Run the $400,000 example with about $600 a month for property taxes and insurance and no other debts. To stay at 36%, you’d need roughly $136,000 a year in gross income for the 15-year. The 30-year gets there at about $110,000.

So a household earning $8,000 a month ($96,000 a year) is already past the line on the 15-year. The mortgage payment alone would be 43% of gross pay. On the 30-year it’s about 34%, before taxes and insurance.

If the 15-year only fits on your best-case budget, it doesn’t fit. Stress-test it with one income gone for six months, or with a big car repair in the same month as the property tax bill.

Get mortgage rate updates by email

I post each Fed decision and the big housing numbers as they land, including the December 9 Fed meeting. Get those posts free in your inbox.

Free. You’ll get my new posts, including these updates. Unsubscribe anytime, and check your spam folder for the confirmation email.

When the 30-Year Is the Smarter Pick

First-time buyers often move within five to ten years. If you sell in year seven, the 15-year’s lifetime interest savings mostly never happen, but the higher payment did, every month. The 30-year’s lower payment can also be what lets you buy in the neighborhood you actually want. If you’re weighing whether a payment that’s double your rent is too much, I ran through that in should you buy a house if the mortgage is double your rent.

Job security matters just as much. Two incomes that could become one, commission pay or self-employment all argue for the lower required payment. You can always pay extra on a 30-year; you can’t pay less on a 15-year.

The mortgage interest deduction gets mentioned a lot here, but it only helps if you itemize. The 2027 standard deduction is $33,200 for married couples filing jointly (my tax brackets and standard deduction guide has the rest). First-year interest on a $400,000 loan at 7.11% is about $28,300, so whether itemizing beats that depends on your state and local taxes and other deductions. Don’t pick a loan term for the write-off.

Paying Extra on a 30-Year: How Close It Gets

This is the option I’d look at hardest. Take the 30-year. Then pay more when you can.

One extra full payment a year (or biweekly payments, which work out to the same thing) pays the loan off about six years early and saves around $136,000 in interest at 7.11%.

Paying the full 15-year amount, $3,473, on the 30-year loan clears it in about 16 years. You’d pay roughly $49,000 more interest than a true 15-year loan. Think of that as the price of being able to drop back to $2,691 in a bad month.

Before you start, ask your servicer how extra money gets applied. Some hold it as an early payment toward next month instead of applying it to principal unless you tell them otherwise.

Two Households, Two Different Answers

Aisha, 29, is buying her first home with a stable government job and little other debt. Her DTI with the 15-year payment would be 27%. Easy call. She takes the 15-year, gets the lower rate and the faster payoff, and still has room in her budget.

Ben and Carla are both self-employed, with income that swings month to month, and they’re buying a $450,000 home. The 15-year payment would push their DTI to 38% in a slow month. They take the 30-year and set up automatic extra principal payments in their stronger months. That keeps them flexible in a downturn while they still pay the loan down faster.

Mistakes That Skew the Comparison

Comparing the rates instead of the payments. The 15-year’s lower rate doesn’t mean a lower payment. Squeezing the loan into half the time more than cancels out the rate difference.

Skipping the emergency fund to make the 15-year work. A bigger payment with no cash cushion is how people end up late on a mortgage they could afford on paper. Build the cushion first, ideally somewhere earning a decent yield like the high-yield savings accounts and CDs I track.

Ignoring the other side of the trade. Every extra dollar into a 7% mortgage is a dollar not going into your 401(k) match or a diversified portfolio. At today’s rates, paying down the mortgage is a guaranteed 7% return, which is hard to beat with safe money. It’s still worth deciding on purpose.

Forgetting about down payment and loan type. A smaller down payment can mean mortgage insurance on top of either term. If you’re putting less than 20% down, see how FHA and conventional loans compare before you lock the term.

What Could Change the Math in 2027

Rates rose to 7.40% in mid-October and have eased for four straight weeks since. Fannie Mae’s October forecast has the 30-year near 7.5% through 2027, and the Mortgage Bankers Association (MBA) expects it to stay above 7%. Both are forecasts, not promises, and the Federal Reserve’s December 9 decision could move them.

If rates do fall a full point or more after you buy, you can refinance into a lower rate or a shorter term then. My refinancing guide covers when that pays off after closing costs. Picking the 30-year today doesn’t lock you out of the 15-year’s benefits later.

I’ll update the payment table here when rates move meaningfully, at least every quarter.

Frequently Asked Questions
QWhat's the rate difference between 15-year and 30-year mortgages right now?
AAbout 0.66 percentage points. Freddie Mac's November 12, 2026 survey had the 15-year fixed at 6.45% and the 30-year at 7.11%.
QHow much more is a 15-year mortgage payment than a 30-year?
AOn a $400,000 loan at those rates, about $782 a month more: $3,473 for the 15-year vs. $2,691 for the 30-year, in principal and interest only.
QIs a 15-year mortgage always the better financial choice?
ANo. It saves a lot of interest, but only if the higher payment fits your budget with room for a job loss or a big repair. If you might move within a few years, much of the savings never materializes.
QCan I get the benefits of a 15-year loan without the higher required payment?
AMostly, yes. Paying the 15-year amount on a 30-year loan at 7.11% pays it off in about 16 years for roughly $49,000 more interest than a true 15-year, and you can drop back to the lower payment anytime.
QWhat debt-to-income ratio should I target before choosing a 15-year mortgage?
AA common guideline is keeping total DTI, all monthly debt payments divided by gross income, comfortably under about 36% including the 15-year payment, taxes and insurance.
Share via:

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.